Chinese Brands Must Build Credibility Before Trust Overseas, Council for Global Brand Building Says
Zhang Yushuo
DATE:  6 hours ago
/ SOURCE:  Yicai
Chinese Brands Must Build Credibility Before Trust Overseas, Council for Global Brand Building Says Chinese Brands Must Build Credibility Before Trust Overseas, Council for Global Brand Building Says

(Yicai) Nov. 16 -- The Council for Global Brand Building, unveiled in September by consultancy iMpact with Yicai as a founding partner, has released the White Paper on the Brand Credibility of Chinese Companies Going Global, putting forward the principle of ‘credibility first, trust later’ for Chinese companies going global.

Since China’s reform and opening-up began in 1978, Chinese companies have been through two stages and are now entering a new stage. The first was the era of product exports, when the country was the ‘world’s factory’ and a good product was enough. Before, overseas buyers wanted high-quality, low-priced products, and distribution channels handled trust-building. But now, as Chinese companies directly foray into foreign markets, quality and price are no longer sufficient.

This is a practical business issue. As firms move into longer-term, more complex overseas operations, factors such as business identifiability, a track record of fulfilling commitments, and compliance and governance carry more weight. A lack of credibility may not manifest as a single, discrete cost, but it can lead to a greater need for explanations, verifications, communication, and additional operational investment, according to the white paper.

Faced with the challenge of earning trust, many companies tend to step up spending on advertising and publicity. However, constant self-promotion makes people doubt a company’s claims, and the company needs others to speak well of it to gain an endorsement effect, said Chris Pereira, founder and chief executive officer of iMpact and chairman of the CGBB, said at a closed-door panel discussion on Nov. 15.

Trust is the result, while credibility is the precondition, said Wang Xiao, director of the Executive Education Center at the International Business School Suzhou, Xi'an Jiaotong-Liverpool University, and chief advisor to the white paper project. Credibility does not come from the company, but from its audience, he added.

A firm cannot control whether others trust it, but it can leave observable and verifiable evidence through its conduct, systems, performance, information disclosure, and corrective action, according to the white paper. Only by building the "credibility conditions" — which provide the basis for external assessment — can trust potentially emerge through long-term interaction, eventually evolving into reliance, entrustment, or a willingness to act, though it does not guarantee that trust will follow.

The CGBB was announced in September during the World Trade Organization's Public Forum in Geneva. With Yicai Media Group as a founding strategic partner, the CGBB released the white paper on Nov. 15.

A 'Diagnostic Mirror’ for Chinese Companies Going Global

To make the abstract concept of credibility something that can be examined and improved, the white paper introduces the first-year Brand Credibility Baseline Assessment System, which breaks a company's credibility conditions into five modules:

1. Identifiability and Information Consistency: Can the business entity behind the brand be accurately identified from the outside, and is its information consistent across channels?

2. External Evaluation and Fulfillment Reputation: After real transactions and partnerships with outside parties, what traceable external records has the company left behind?

3. Compliance and Governance: Does the company meet the entry rules of its target market, and does it face legal, regulatory, or governance risks that call for particular attention?

4. Transparency and Responsiveness: When complaints or disputes arise, can the company state the facts accurately, take action, and leave verifiable evidence of remediation?

5. Responsible Practices and Localization: As its operations lengthen, has the company built up a sustained record of local hiring, partnerships, and responsible practices?

The system looks at both the company's performance and how well the evidence supports each judgment. “Not found” does not automatically mean “no,” and “insufficient data” does not result in a zero score.

For serious legal, regulatory, or governance matters, the system has a separate major-risk mechanism that cannot be averaged out by positive results in other modules, and it will constrain the overall status. Cross-border professional platforms, such as LinkedIn, are considered only when they establish identity in the relevant market or industry. Using a given platform does not, by itself, earn a higher status.

The framework is like a “bronze mirror,” said Yang Yudong, editor-in-chief of Yicai. He claimed that the CGBB white paper is like "the first time you are given a mirror, and this mirror may be a bronze mirror of ancient China.” It may be blurry at first, but you can look into it again and again, and the image may grow clearer each time.

Localization and AI as Double Test

Credibility is ultimately tested in specific environments. Bruce Zou, a senior researcher at the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania, has worked in US local government, where he took part in cross-border investment and trade projects. He believes that the next round of globalization is highly localized, as companies need to set up a sound local capital structure and integrate into communities through local culture.

Along with localization, companies also face a new test from generative artificial intelligence. In fact, generative AI is becoming an information intermediary that shapes external judgments of credibility, the white paper noted. Key information must be discoverable, verifiable, and consistent across sources to secure “machine-verifiable credibility.”

AI's judgments depend on credible sources, Pereira noted, adding that “media is the cornerstone of AI.”

However, the white paper cautions that AI's synthesized output is not independent fact-checking. Simply adding large volumes of company-owned content does not guarantee that AI will reach more reliable judgments. The point is not to try to get large models to "say good things," but to accumulate, in day-to-day operations, objective facts that can withstand verification.

The white paper also spells out the limits of the first-year assessment, offering a basic diagnostic methodology rather than a large-sample empirical study. Whether improvements in credibility conditions can translate into customer acquisition and business results remains to be tested with data from subsequent pilot assessments of real companies.

Editor: Futura Costaglione

Follow Yicai Global on
Keywords:   GGBB,white paper,credibility